Skip to main content

Navigating geoeconomics at the India economic conclave


At the 11th edition of India economic conclave I had the pleasure of listening to luminaries like Minister Nirmala Sitharaman,Dr Gita Gopinath, famed entrepreneur Sridhar Vembu and several other leaders in the business world. It was a very humbling experience for me to be present in the midst of inspiring personalities who are painstakingly pushing India to become a $10 Trillion economy and a fully developed nation by 2047. 

The overarching theme of the event was navigating geoeconomics. It is no secret that like many other developing nations India's economy is heavily dependent upon the US. President Trump's decision to put America first has not gone well with several nations who have accused him of implementing policies that threaten to destabilize the world economy,in their opinion. Many have pointed out that the USA is violating all rules of trade that it established in the first place. 

There is some truth to that argument. But it fails to answer the most basic question. Why should the USA not look out for its own interests? 

When discussing the USA many analysts fail to take into account that the USA too was once a colonised nation that fought imperial powers to gain independence and developed through long,exhausting years step by step. The hard work the Americans put in over the centuries has placed them where they are today. The foundations laid by Monroe became the cornerstone of US trade and foreign policy which sought to protect American nations from colonial dumping of goods in North and LATAM. 

The Nixon/Kissinger administration invested in China with the explicit goal of democratising Chinese polity. But that did not happen. In fact the Chinese communist party actively sabotaged US industries for its own gain. Today US corporations NVIDIA,Apple,Microsoft and so many more employ and enthusiastically engage with communist Chinese politburo to generate more profits. 

Throughout the 70’s American investment has created the so-called Asian tiger economies and what has it gotten in return? Nothing but ingratitude, more competition , loss of wealth and jobs from its own country. Why would anyone want to continue with an arrangement that is so unbalanced?

How does the so-called trade with Asian nations benefit the average American citizen? Well an argument could be made that these corporations gain more market share and international exposure. But it's clear to see who gained more [1].

Meanwhile many of LATAM states are still lagging behind in tech and have paradoxically started engaging with China instead of America. The original ideals of Monroe which sought to empower the American nations seem to have been lost in this geopolitical game. 

The voices in the USA are growing strong. The American people want someone who can look out for American interests and not be a lackey to unanswerable private corporations who have grown so powerful that they can change policies. Organisations that are simply too big to fail. That's all president Trump is doing —what's best for the Americans. Making sure that American jobs are protected and that only those immigrants who are critical to the US economy are given precedence. 
Some people argue that this protectionist attitude will not be beneficial in the long run for the USA. A few decades ago China was not even a competitor. Now it's a threat. Nearly all of the west is actively trying to uncouple its dependence on China and build more robust supply chains. At least that's what many would like to believe even when the evidence points to the fact that the trade between the US and China has increased year on year[2]. 

That's where India comes in. India seems to promise America a reliable and democratic partner in Asia. But from an American point of view India is a net importer of technology. India gains more in a partnership with America. Every year $27 Billion dollars are sent in remittances alone by Indian immigrants in the USA. Not to mention the uncountable wealth that is generated by American corporations headquartered in India. 

Despite this the rhetoric in Indian media and polity is certainly anti American. Recently the Minister of External Affairs Dr S Jaishankar dropped even the pretense of being friendly with America by publicly endorsing a reset of ties with China [6]. The context matters because just a few years ago his stance was pro American and anti chinese. 

The USA questions India's commitment to Quad because of its active involvement in BRICS. As far as American policy makers are concerned India is not trustworthy and frankly it's hard to blame them. It is clear to see that India has not emerged from that policy of Non alignment ,which it now calls multi alignment perhaps with an intention to misdirect, that defined Nehru's terms. Which is ironic considering how China has prioritised good relations with the USA since at least the 1800s.  

Geopolitically India lacks strength. Well yes many analysts claim that India has a long coastline from where it can ‘project power’ in the Indian Ocean and ‘safeguard’ interests that are shared by the USA. The QUAD was certainly founded on these principles but the fact is that India is not the only nation that offers these advantages. The USA can just as easily partner with any nation to the west of India or with any nation in central Asia to gain similar advantages. It has certainly done so through partnerships with Pakistan, Thailand and Vietnam. Yet despite this the Indian diaspora remains a source of consolation. As it has established itself quite firmly in the USA and continues to act as a diplomatic bridge between the two governments. 

Mr Vembu's talk touched upon these themes. From what I understood he was of the opinion that India needs to build its own technology. One this aspect I am in full agreement with him. Geopolitical games are hardly strategic despite what they may seem like to someone who is a casual observer.

Many of these ministers ,bureaucrats and diplomats give an aura that they are doing something really important and significant. Nothing could be further from the truth. All they do is react. In fact, reactive is an apt word to describe modern geopolitics. Kissinger called it realpolitik, a term he borrowed from a German journalist. 

Under the cover of pragmatism, realism,achievable goals, diplomacy and what not realpolitik fails to make choices. Or to be more blunt it refuses to make one. It doesn't take a stand. Strategy is about making deliberate choices after looking at tradeoffs and picking the one which positions you to win. 

America has or at least used to have a strategy. It used its technology as a geopolitical leverage. Tech transfers to SEA or to China or to nations in the EU come with strings attached. They happen when the US is already 2 steps ahead of the game. The nations to which tech is transferred are always lagging behind. No matter how strong the economies in the SEA become they will never win or lead just become prosperous but impotent. 

This is why it's important to ‘homebrew’ tech. England did it centuries ago and it placed them at the top. The US did it much later and it leads the world. Anyone who wants to compete or surpass the USA will have to do the same. There is no other way.

 It's impossible to catch up by simply following the footsteps of a leader. 

However there are other voices. Many claim that the US is in decline. Supposing that it were true America has embedded itself so deeply in the world that it's quite possible that someone else would easily advance America's cause. It might be Canada or even one of many prosperous US states. This is the benefit of free trade. It allows you to create redundancy and the US has a lot of redundancy built in. 

History repeats itself over and over and over. The industrialisation of the Chinese nation and the events that are taking place today are not new to a careful observer of history. A century before the same events transpired in Germany. Today Germany proudly claims itself to be an industrialised nation. A country that innovated and pushed the boundaries of science and technology. But turn back the pages of history and you'll find a slightly different ,a bit more uncomfortable truth. 

German businessmen,engineers and scientists relied upon free trade to reverse engineer goods, patents to seed their own economy. Which is why List’s theory seems so hollow. Without free trade it would have been impossible for Germany or Japan or any other nation who developed to acquire tech to reverse engineer [3-4]. Free trade won absolutely while protectionism has failed to produce a single winner. 

It's also interesting to note that while industrialized America focused on a respectful trade between nations, both of the so-called nationalised economies of Japan and Germany turned into colonial powers. 

I thought it was a bit hypocritical for the speakers to suggest domestic protection in India while advocating for free markets in the USA. 

Another question was raised : Does a strong economy make a strong nation? Many speakers seemed to believe so. I have my doubts. Many nations have strong economies today. Singapore,Japan,Germany,Saudi Arabia,Israel,Qatar,UAE,South Korea. All of them are militarily occupied by the USA. China, despite all of its huffing and puffing, seeks to placate the USA just for the privilege of being able to trade with the Americans. In exchange the USA allows china not just trade but a share in power. Penny Wong is the FM of AU, a five eyes nation. Germany is no different,former German FM Annalena Baerbock has been appointed as the president of UNGA in New York. 

So many Chinese people today are leading US semicon hubs. The USA towers over China. Being a strong economy made them rich but not free. Do they even value freedom over comfort? 

US firms generate around $310B in China. I don't ever foresee the Chinese saying no to even a fraction of that money. This is why BRICS won't ever get anywhere and is definitely not the voice of the global south. 

African nations need to carefully analyse what has happened in Asia. They have little choice in terms of financing, yet their strong diaspora in the USA can position them advantageously vis-a-vis the EU or Asia. 

REFERENCES 
1 How did China’s trade surplus hit $1 trillion?
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/12/9/how-did-chinas-trade-surplus-hit-1-trillion

2 China’s trade resilience shows that US tariffs aren’t everything
https://think.ing.com/snaps/chinas-trade-resilience-shows-that-the-future-of-trade-is-more-than-just-us-tariffs/

3 American influence on German manufacturing before World War I: the case of the Ludwig Loewe Company
https://books.openedition.org/irhis/1885?lang=en

4 Catching-Up and Falling Behind: Knowledge Spillover from American to German Machine Toolmakers
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/227405175_Catching-Up_and_Falling_Behind_Knowledge_Spillover_from_American_to_German_Machine_Toolmakers

5 China says BRICS not seeking ‘confrontation’ after Trump tariff threat
https://www.arabnews.com/node/2607195/world

6 EAM's visit to China and meeting with Chinese Foreign Minister
https://www.mea.gov.in/press-releases.htm?dtl/39803/EAMs_visit_to_China_and_meeting_with_Chinese_Foreign_Minister

Akshat Jiwan Sharma

Strategy Consultant--Innovation/ Materials science/International relations/Telecommunications/Digital Transformation/Partnerships 

Mobile/whatsapp:+919654119771 

email:getellobed@gmail.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Workforce development isn't enough for innovation

Being one of the fastest growing regions in the world, Asia Pacific’s stature in the scientific community is growing as is the region's ambition to play a greater role  in shaping research through science diplomacy. I have had the good fortune of connecting with delegates from Singapore and South Korea in conferences last year. Similarly I had the opportunity to engage virtually with researchers from Australia during Australian Academy of Science’s flagship event ‘ Science at the shine dome ’ in 2025.  A few days ago I attended the International Science Council’s ( Asia Pacific chapter) quarterly meeting. Three things that stood out during my interactions were : focus on workforce development, democratization of science for greater public participation and emphasis on sustainability.  All three issues are highly relevant but for Asia Pacific in particular workforce development takes special priority as STEM courses are often viewed as a path to a prosperous f...

Why does collapsing a bubble with a sound wave produce light?

My thoughts on a reddit discussion  https://www.reddit.com/r/AskPhysics/comments/1lwxxc3/comment/n2jx8gp/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button The collapsing of a bubble with sound wave leads to the emission of light in a phenomenon known as sonoluminescnce.  The bubble collapse is rapid and the gas inside the core doesn't have time to exchange heat with the surroundings as it's compressed rapidly leading to what is known as adiabatic compression.  This compression heats up the gas to very high temp. The exact temperatures are inferred from the spectrum of emission which is thought to be a blackbody. But some sophisticated models have also been developed that put the temp in the range 5000k-20000k some even higher.  There's also debate on whether the bubble emission spectrum is truly a blackbody or is it line emission or bremsstrahlung? Personally I think its a mix of all three. The pressures create...

The African Century

Over the past 5 years I have been advocating  unification and industrialisation of Africa. During this time I have had the pleasure of interacting with several African business and political leaders from Tanzania,Kenya,Nigeria, South Africa,Uganda,Egypt,Sudan,Malawi,Liberia and more who share this vision. Africa is one of the largest contiguous land masses on the planet,with one of the world's youngest populations, an immense coastline ,deserts, mineral resources and arable land.  Its location provides it with supreme geopolitical advantage that can potentially project it's influence over all of Asia and the EU. Yet historical factors combined with present economic conditions has not only prevented Africa from actualising its potential but has also made it entirely dependent upon developed nations to satisfy the demands of modern nation states.  Predictably what we have seen in Africa is a continuation of extractive economics where African states supply raw ma...

The twisted fairy tales of blasphemous —stories of religious devotion, sadism and surrender

I had never played a souls-like game before,so when I saw that blasphemous was on sale earlier this summer I decided to buy and give it a try. I had heard a lot of good things about this game but it still managed to surprise me with the depth of its world.  The entire game takes place in a small town of cvstodia but the amount of lore it manages to pack is simply amazing. Rooted in Spanish christian mythology weaving together themes of religious devotion,inquisition,fanaticism, penitence and authority , the main story in the game is very unsettling.  Those who like fairy tales will find the narration familiar with each segment concluding with a moral lesson — but that lesson is entirely twisted and almost nightmarish. Exactly the opposite of a happy ending in a classic fairy tale.  The 'miracle’, a god-like entity, grants people's wishes in the most ironic ,punishing manner possible and people bear these tortures without complaining, thinking of it as a blessing.  Cv...

Energy asymmetry in AI: Who gets to host the future?

8 Jan 2026 I thank the New York Energy Forum for organising a discussion on how  AI is   Shaping the Global Future. Dr. Carolyn Kissane,Associate Dean of New York University’s Center   for Global Affairs and Director of NYU’s SPS Energy, Climate Justice, and Sustainability Lab , Mr.  Douglas Giuffre Executive Director and Head of Americas Power & Renewables  at S&P Global Energy, Mr Michael Pearce ,Chief US Economist at Oxford Economics presented their thoughts on implications of AI on geopolitics, energy and economics respectively. The session was moderated by Mr. Atul Arya, Senior Vice President and Chief Energy Strategist at S&P Global. AI continues to create headlines and draw passionate responses from experts in technology, governance and public policy. As with any new technology there are concerns around job security,the cost of operation and even on its effect on climate change . Some of these concerns are simply anxiety while others...

Update on the ASM committee meeting on the State of the Art in Material Upcycling for Additive Manufacturing

May 15 2026 I thank ASM sustainable manufacturing committee for organising a highly informative talk by Dr Sweta Baruah on the topic of Materials Upcycling in Additive manufacturing.  As it stands AM is far more material efficient than traditional manufacturing processes— producing less waste than subtractive manufacturing techniques (milling/turning/drilling/grinding).  Yet feedstock cost in AM remains high due to energy intensive processes used in its manufacturing. Typical powderisation techniques using gas or water atomisation consume much energy as do wire extrusion processes.  The desire to cut down the input energy serves as a powerful motivator to develop processes that can lower the cost and make AM more sustainable.  Traditional melt processing technologies for making powder or wire help with the reusability of waste streams and reduce energy input because compared to fresh feedstock there is no need for crushing ,chemical treatment,reduction etc.  Yet...

If you like RPGs you should play Knights of The Old Republic

This summer on star wars day I decided to give Knights of the old Republic (KOTOR) a try. I like star wars franchise but I'm not too deep into the lore ,so initially , I was a bit undecided about the game but took a chance since I had heard from so many people that it's one of the best RPGs ever made. After finishing the game I've got to say that it's reputation is definitely well deserved. The game leans heavily towards narration and your choices can have long lasting impact on how the story plays out. Combat is real time action but you don't control characters directly rather issue commands via a pause menu. It takes a while to get used to but works very well especially on mobile touch screens. I felt that some abilities are way overpowered. Especially the light side ones that buff your characters and grant them extra turns.Even a dark ability' like destroy droid can clear out some of the toughest opponents in a few turns. From what I understand this game is b...

The Promise of Physical AI

11 Mar 2026 Yesterday at the 60th Edition of Cobotalks organised by I-Hub Foundation for Cobotics Technology Innovation Hub of IIT Delhi, I had a chance to attend a talk on physical AI by Dr Santanu Chaudhary, Former Professor, Department of Electrical Engineering, IIT Delhi. This talk came just weeks after the India AI impact summit but I was excited nonetheless to learn more about some of the academic aspects of AI.  Dr. Santanu emphasized that while chatbots have taken over the mindspace there is more to AI than just interactions with a server on the cloud. The chatbots represent a more general-purpose intelligence, they are quietly disrupting several industries in the ‘knowledge-work’ space but physical AI is narrow task specific intelligence that has applications in industrial automation and handling tasks that are either too dangerous for humans or too much of a chore.  Autonomous vehicles are a great example of physical AI. They have demonstrated that it is...

Interdependence and strategic autonomy in a world that may no longer cooperate

9 Dec 2025  At the global boardroom organised by the financial times I got the opportunity to learn from decision makers & understand their approach to deal with a world that is facing constant disruption and where economic policy, geopolitics, technology, energy, and leadership are increasingly intertwined.  FT brought in a diverse set of speakers: Christine Lagarde — President, European Central Bank,Akash Palkhiwala —COO, Qualcomm,Eimear Bonner — CFO, Chevron Corporation,Janet Henry — Global Chief Economist, HSBC, Izabella Teixeira — Member, International Advisory Board & Former Brazilian Environment Minister ,Antti Häkkänen — Minister of Defence, Finland , Oana-Silvia Țoiu — Minister of Foreign Affairs, Romania, Lesley O’Connor — Founder & Executive Chair, SupergridEurope among others to speak on themes spanning economics, geopolitics, technology, energy, and governance.  Today in this interconnected world the decisions that one nation takes ...