In his book do aliens speak physics physicist Daniel Whiteson asks thought provoking questions on the nature of reality and casts doubt on our current physical understanding of the universe. What if our theories don't describe true reality? This is an important question to ask and one that has been asked by many philosophers. It forms the basis of ontology a branch of philosophy that deals with the nature of reality. It is true that scientific theories describe a subset of reality and it's difficult to apply them outside of their domain. Particles physics can't predict hurricanes yet. Aliens may choose different assumptions and come up with different theories. It would challenge our understanding of reality but won't change reality itself. From a philosophical point of view it might be helpful to remove the foundations upon which our theories rest and see what remains. If you can get rid of that too then it's not fundamental. If you can't then it is. ...
There is ongoing debate about the exact mechanisms that cause diamond formation in the microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition (MPCVD) process. While it’s well established that methane (CH4) and hydrogen (H2)are the key gases Hydrogen etches away non-diamond (sp2) carbon, while carbon from CH₄ contributes to diamond (sp3) growth. Yet the exact carbon-containing species responsible for diamond growth ,whether CH3 radicals, C2 dimers, or other species are the dominant contributors are not known. It's also not clear what surface reactions and growth mechanisms contribute to growth and how these species attach to diamond surfaces and stabilize sp3 bonds. While the general scheme is agreed upon, the precise atomic and plasma-chemical pathways that make diamond grow in MPCVD[2] are still a topic of active research and debate. Here's what I think happens Hydrogenation of carbon structures adds H atoms to carbon.This process promotes sp3 hybridization in formerly sp2 ,sp carbons...